Skip to content

How do you know if your photography website is any good? A 6-part self-check

You can’t tell by looking at it, and an SEO score won’t tell you either. One brand photographer I audited this year had a site that scored 100 out of 100 on Lighthouse’s SEO test, while Google showed her homepage 12,648 times in a year and it got 35 clicks.

A good photography website holds up on 6 things at once (useful, usable, desirable, findable, accessible and credible), and how it looks is only one of them. So I check a site the way a client meets it, one part at a time, with a yes or no question for each.

TL;DR: Answer the 6 questions in the table below with a yes or no, then ask 4 questions on every main page, fix the weakest part first, and get outside eyes for what you can’t see yourself.

What are the 6 parts of a good photography website?

They’re useful, usable, desirable, findable, accessible and credible. My own list of adjectives for a great photography website goes like this: obvious, attractive, easy to use, enjoyable, satisfying, mobile-friendly, fast, reliable, fresh, unique. They’re all true, and I can’t check a single one of them on your site until I turn it into a question.

The 6 parts come from Peter Morville’s user experience honeycomb, and I’ve used them in my talks on UX for years. Here’s what each one covers on a photography website, and the question I’d ask:

Part What it covers on a photography site The question to ask
Useful What’s on your homepage and service pages, prices, contact details Does the site answer what a client came to ask?
Usable Speed, forms, menus, how it all works on a phone Can a client go from your homepage to a sent inquiry without anything in the way?
Desirable Your images, your brand, the feel of the site Does it look like the work you want to be hired for?
Findable Basic SEO, navigation, search Can Google and a visitor both reach the pages that sell?
Accessible Alt text, contrast, real text instead of text in images Can everyone read and use it, people with disabilities included?
Credible Your copy, your personality, your name and the small trust signals Would a stranger believe what the site tells them?

Morville’s honeycomb has a 7th facet, valuable, and I leave it out on purpose. He wrote that a site has to deliver value to the people behind it, which for a business means the bottom line, and for a photographer that’s inquiries and bookings. That’s the result the other 6 add up to, and you can’t see it by looking at a page, so I treat it as the scoreboard.

If the scoreboard is what worries you (inquiries slowed down, or never really started), my guide on why a photography website isn’t bringing inquiries is the faster place to start.

Useful means the site answers what a client came to ask

A useful site answers the questions a client would otherwise have to email you about, on the page where they’re deciding.

Another brand photographer I audited this year had a warm, personal site with prices on it, but her brand photography page, the main page she sells from, had no questions and answers at all. So her action plan adds a 6-question FAQ there: cost, what’s included, how many photos, turnaround, location and camera nerves.

The site with the 35 clicks had a headshots page that ended on a vague line with no price and no button, so a visitor who was ready to book had nowhere to go next. The fix in her plan is a short block with the price, a button, and links to 2 client stories.

The check: read your main service page as a client who’s about to book, and note every question you’d still have to email about.

Usable means nothing gets in the way, especially on a phone

A usable site lets someone go from your homepage to a sent inquiry without waiting, guessing, or typing more than they’re ready to.

The site with the 35 clicks also had one contact form at the bottom of every page, with 7 fields and 5 of them required, phone number included. I suggested cutting the required fields to 3 (first name, email and message) and keeping the form only on the Contact page and the 2 main service pages.

Cutting the form back helps the speed too. On Lighthouse’s mobile test, the homepage on that site took 12.1 seconds to show its largest image and jumped around while the 4-image gallery grid at the top loaded, and the form loaded Google’s reCAPTCHA script on every page. Those were the 2 biggest causes I could measure, so the plan replaces the grid with a section background or a single image block and takes the form off most pages.

A slider can cause the same kind of delay: the other brand photographer’s homepage took 8.1 seconds to show its main image on a phone, because the slider loaded every slide as a background image the browser finds late.

If your form is the weak spot, I wrote about what a photography contact page needs in more detail.

The check: open your homepage on your phone, on mobile data rather than your home Wi-Fi, and send yourself an inquiry. Notice every moment you waited, and every field you’d rather have skipped.

Desirable is the part you’ve probably already got right

Desirable is about your images and the feeling the site gives, and since it’s your own work and your own taste on the page, it’s often the strongest of the 6.

On the site with the 35 clicks, the design was good and I wouldn’t have touched it. And some of the photographers who write to me have already paid for a redesign that brought no new work.

But it’s your clients who have to like the site, and your taste and theirs don’t always match. You might honestly think a splash page or music that plays on arrival sets the mood, and you might also be wrong.

The check: look at the first images on your homepage. Are they the kind of work you want more of? Then ask someone who isn’t a photographer what kind of photographer you are, based on the homepage alone.

Homepage of Kati Photography in Zurich, with the menu above a photo of parents lifting their baby in a sunlit autumn forest and the word Love

Kati Schneider‘s homepage opens on one photo of a family playing in golden autumn light, so anyone landing there can tell she photographs families before reading a word.

Findable means Google and your visitors can both reach the pages that sell

Findable has 2 halves: people finding your site from Google and other places online, and people finding the right page once they’re on it.

On the site with 12,648 impressions and 35 clicks, the homepage title and headline didn’t name the specialty or the place, so Google had little reason to rank it higher, and the people who did see it had little reason to click.

The other brand photographer’s plan works on the same half: new page titles and descriptions, a block of structured data that tells Google what the business is and where, and a listing in a directory of branding photographers where clients in her country actually look.

Inside the site with the 35 clicks, 166 pages linked to the Services and Contact pages, 18 linked to the brand photography page she most wanted to sell, 7 to her headshots and none to her corporate headshots. Clients can only book what they can find, so her plan rebuilds the menu and footer around her actual offers and gives the services page a headshots card and a text link under every card.

Links are also how Google finds your pages and understands how they connect (Google’s own guide to links explains it), so a page that hardly anything links to looks less important, to visitors and probably to Google too.

The check: search your specialty and your town in a private browser window and see where you show up. Then start from your homepage and make sure every service you sell is one click away, in the menu.

Homepage of Marian Kraus Photography with the headline Chicago Architectural and Industrial Photographer above four architecture photos

Marian Kraus‘s homepage headline names his specialty and his city, Chicago architectural and industrial photographer, right above four of his architecture photos.

Accessible means nobody gets locked out

An accessible site works for people with poor eyesight or a screen reader (and for anyone reading a phone in bright sunlight), and on a photography site it mostly comes down to contrast and alt text.

The other brand photographer’s homepage had one button on its first screen on a phone, pale peach on a pale background. Her plan uses a darker shade of the same peach for text and solid buttons, so her colors stay and the buttons become readable.

Alt text was missing on 89 images on her site, and on 72 on the site with the 35 clicks. Screen readers read it out loud, and Google says it uses alt text, along with computer vision and the content of the page, to understand what an image shows. So the same few words help a visitor who can’t see the photo and the search engine deciding what it’s about.

The check: open your site on your phone outdoors and try to read every button and every line of text. Then look at a few portfolio images in your site builder and see whether they have alt text describing what’s in them.

Credible means a stranger believes what the site tells them

Credibility is everything that makes a stranger trust you before you’ve met: your copy and your personality on the page, plus a lot of small signals nobody consciously notices until one of them is off.

On the site with the 35 clicks, the header used one business name while the footer and Google Maps used another. A locations page was live with the site builder’s placeholder text still on it, and 4 pages that still ranked or still had links pointing to them showed “page not found”, the old pricing page among them. Small stuff like that has nothing to do with design, and it’s exactly what makes a careful client hesitate.

The plan for that site puts one name in one form everywhere, finishes or hides the half-built pages and redirects the dead ones.

The check: google your business name and compare what comes up with your header, your footer and your Google Business Profile if you have one. Then click every link in your menu and footer, and read your About page as if you’d never met yourself.

4 questions to ask on every main page

The 6 parts tell you what to check across the whole site, and these 4 questions are how I’d review one page at a time:

  1. Why are people coming to this page? What do they expect to find?
  2. When first-time visitors land here, can they find what they came for quickly?
  3. What’s the fluff that could come off the page?
  4. Which page should they go to after this one?

That last one is where call-to-action buttons come in, since every main page should end with one planned next step.

The 4 questions are hard to answer about your own site, because you already know where everything is. If you can’t review it yourself, browse a few photographers’ websites you like and notice what you enjoy on them, or ask friends or colleagues to try yours and listen for the comments that come up more than once.

Which part should you fix first?

The weakest one, which is usually not the one you’d enjoy working on. In both audits I mentioned, the fix list was mostly words, links and settings, and neither site needed a redesign.

Everybody has access to the same information these days (blog posts, podcasts, articles like this one), and the tools and platforms are relatively cheap, so you also have to act on what you learn. Once the technical problems are fixed, the work left is the harder stuff, like writing the answers and the copy that show you’re the right photographer.

If your site gets a yes on all 6 questions, it’s a good website, even if you’d still like to change the fonts. And a no or two just tells you where to start. If you’d rather go through your own site item by item, I also made a separate checklist for that, the Website Self-Check, with 22 yes or no checks you can tick off.

A self-check can’t give you a stranger’s eyes, though, and that’s what my website audit for photographers is for: I go through all 6 parts on your real site and give you the fixes in the order I’d do them, with titles and descriptions already written for you.

Which of the 6 would YOU grade lowest on your own site?

Off-topic or inflammatory comments may be moderated.
Please add VALUE to the web, thanks!

Want expert eyes on your photography website?

Website Audit: A complete manual review of your site's design, speed, SEO, and UX, with a prioritized action plan (add a strategy call if you want one). 100% of your audit fee is credited toward any project over $1,000 booked within a month of delivery.

Website Makeover: Targeted improvements to make your existing site faster, more modern, and better at converting visitors into clients.

SEO & AI visibility: done-for-you technical and local SEO, plus a check of how ChatGPT and Google's AI answers describe you. $1,500 on WordPress, $1,200 on other platforms.

 

Search for other articles:

Or explore these related categories:

Fix Your Photography Website in 7 Days

One website fix a day for 7 days, then my newsletter every Tuesday on design, SEO, copywriting and marketing. You also get the Optimization Kit, a private page with the 60+ Photography Website Mistakes PDF, the About page checklist, the Homepage Checklist, 3 free email courses (SEO, design, blogging), the 3 planning workbooks, the Lead Delivery Test, the Website Owner’s Manual and recorded interviews.
My best advice, in your inbox, free.

No spam ever. You are free to unsubscribe at any time. 

Photographer looking through a camera with a long lens

“If you haven’t subscribed to Alex’s newsletter yet you’re a nutjob!”

Photographer in a knit hat shooting in a lupine field

“SO MUCH good stuff in there – where have you been all my life!!”

Smiling man in a black polo shirt

“Definitely worthwhile subscribing  – always full of great info.”

Woman laughing in front of a leaf mural

“The most useful out of everything I get via email. So thank you!”

Smiling man with glasses, hat and vest

“So much interesting content. It got my head spinning.”

Woman smiling at her laptop in a cafe

“It’s so comprehensive and I love Alex’s brutal honesty”

Photographer in a magenta top holding a camera

“One of the very few emails that I allow to show up in my inbox.”

Sports photographer with a camera on a football field

“Straightforward, to the point, no nonsense, solid information.”

Photographer sitting on the floor with her camera, black and white

“You have so much good information – it’s almost overwhelming!”

Smiling woman in a red top outdoors

“The best information & advice on photography websites anywhere.”